Peer Review
Prof. Dr. Mirco Schoenfeld
It’s your turn
Review your colleague’s contributions
considering the following
points.
Try to be as explicit as possible. Try to verbalize your assumptions
and making your thoughts as transparent as you can.
Be constructive. Be friendly. Be fair.
The idea
The idea.
- Is the idea generally intriguing?
- How innovative or even disruptive is the idea?
Specific parts
Specific parts:
Does the text contain the following points?
If yes, how
explicitly/good/clear/insufficient?
- Does the text mention clear objectives?
- Does the text mention clear KPIs and how they will be measured?
- Does the text mention the origin of the data?
- Does the text critically reflect on the approach?
Data Processes
Data Processes
- What are the relevant data?
- How is the data gathered?
- Does the data really describe the problem at hand?
- What are the KPIs and quality metrics for your idea?
